Tuesday, August 22

What To Do with Too Many Tomatoes? Grab the Blender!

Gorgeous bounty from the kitchen garden—and lots of it.

I'm blaming the heat.

In the past 48 hours, not only have I been unable to come up with an interesting little story to go along with this new recipe, or figure out a nice way to photograph it, I can't even think of a decent name for it.

If I call one more creation 'Susan's Super Simple Summer Something,' people are going to start thinking there's something wrong with me.

And the other day I did start thinking something was wrong with me. I kinda sorta almost started getting tired of eating tomatoes. At first this didn't seem possible. After all those months of patiently yearning—not to mention all that sheep manure fertilizer I hauled up to the garden—had my child-like thrill over that first ripe tomato already given way to the glutton's nonchalance?

Then I realized that I've already been enjoying ripe tomatoes from the garden
for six weeks now. Six weeks of pretty much getting all of my 5 to 9 daily servings of fruit and vegetables from tomatoes. And then I didn't feel so bad anymore.

But I still had a problem. Everywhere I turned in the kitchen I saw ripe tomatoes in desperate need of being dealt with. And while the rest of the world apparently gathers up all of their imperfect, overripe, questionable looking tomatoes and roasts them—and while I love the deep flavor of roasted tomatoes—turning on the oven for 8 straight hours in August to cook up anything is never gonna happen in my kitchen.

So I threw them in the blender instead.

And I created yet another super simple summer recipe. That I can't come up with a name for.

Fortunately (while I was slurping it up with a spoon)* I did manage to come up with several ways to use this sublime stuff.

The most obvious is to pour it over pretty much any kind of salad you feel like tossing together (including my
Colors Of Summer Salad). Or you could drizzle it over a platter of sliced tomatoes and mozzarella that you've garnished with fresh basil sprigs. I think it would be fantastic in a chilled pasta salad.

If you happen to feel like turning on the oven for a much more reasonable one hour, you could whip up
some homemade pita breads, stuff them with fresh baby spinach and other veggies and perhaps a few chunks of cheese, pour on a little dressing, and eat your salad as a sandwich. Or you could have warm pitas filled with some nice cooked Italian sausage, slices of roasted red pepper, a few chopped tomatoes, and topped with a splash of dressing.

You could use it to liven up deviled eggs or egg salad or even chicken salad. Make it thick and use it as a dip for slices of
crunchy sweet peppers, carrot sticks, or hunks of raw cauliflower. I think you get the idea.

I just can't believe that with all
the cute critters and crazy goings-on around here I wasn't able to come up with a better excuse for my lack of creativity in the naming department than the stupid heat. Maybe there really is something wrong with me.

Oh well. At least I'm still eating my tomatoes.

Susan's Seven Second Tomato Glut Solution

One 16-ounce carton sour cream or yogurt (or a combination)
Several vine-ripened tomatoes, preferably heirloom & organic
Your favorite basil pesto (you'll find my recipe here

Spoon the sour cream into a blender. Toss in as many halved or quartered tomatoes as you like, cutting away any questionable looking spots if you're dealing with overripe or imperfect bounty. The more tomatoes, the thinner the dressing; meaty, plum tomatoes will give you a thicker end result than regular "salad" or "slicing" tomatoes.

Add a few large spoonfuls of pesto. Whirl it all up in the blender, then turn it off and take a little taste. Add more tomatoes and/or pesto if desired. Sprinkle in some salt if needed. Whirl once more and enjoy however you like.

—Use thick Greek yogurt or yogurt cheese in place of some or all of the sour cream or yogurt if you want a thicker, dip-like consistency.

arugula pesto instead of basil pesto.

September 2007 update: This recipe inspired the High Kicking Tomato Dressing I put on my Mexican Jumping Bean Slaw, which also makes great vegetarian tacos.

* I know, I know, I tend to do that a lot. In fact, I've consumed quite a number of meals standing in the kitchen, wielding a large spoon. Just the other night I had pesto for dinner. Not pesto pasta, not pesto pizza, just pesto. Straight out of the food processor. It was really quite tasty.

It's not my fault, though. I inherited an incredibly vigorous taste-testing gene from my mother. You should see us with a bowl of cookie batter.

© FarmgirlFare.com, the well fertilized foodie farm blog where Farmgirl Susan shares stories & photos of her crazy country life on 240 remote Missouri acres.


  1. Totally, TOTALLY, slurp it up with a spoon!

  2. Oh! Oh! How about over a baked potato? We often eat potatoes for lunch with chopped, steamed broccoli, melted cheese, and roasted red pepper sauce on top. I think this would be a delicious alternative to the pepper sauce.
    Yum, yum!

  3. What a great tomato photo. And I think this may be your most inspired recipe title yet. I have a ton of tomatoes that need to get roasted, but I think I'm about ready to switch to pasta sauce. I"ll make some of this too. Saturday I'll be doing that all day I guess, since I'm being imprisoned within the school the other days. (Now I know how the students feel.)

  4. Two suggestions for roasted tomatoes:

    1) Do the oven overnight. It's low heat.

    2) Try my recipe, which takes much less time. I call them "Godiva Tomatoes."

    XOX to you, beautiful.

  5. I used to can tomatoe juice to make soup with all winter long, it's the best!

  6. Where did you get the notion that you lack creativity? You would have a cow if you knew how often I throw away fruit & veg cos it's passed over and I had no idea what to do with it. But then when it arrives in my kitchen from Spain/Argentina/New Zealand etc. via the refrigerated hell holes that are our supermarkets, then you might forgive me, since the bloomin' stuff has no flavour anyway. Ahhh, to be stranded on your farm....

    Got your note, will reply shortly. X

  7. mhmmm, this sounds gorgeous :-))
    ... but just in case: it's possible simply to put the tomatoes in zip bags and freeze them. Whenever you need some fresh tomato flavor in no-fresh-tomato-anywhere time, they can easily be peeled by shortly splashing the still frozen tomatoes with hot water.

  8. we went to france for 2 weeks in our d.i.y. campervan, first gathering up and taking with us all the ripe tomatoes our allotment had to offer! so many of them!!! containers full! we survived on tomatoes for over a week, across the length and width of france, even giving them away to the helpful lady in the tourist office! and now we're back, yet more have grown! yum!!! enjoy them! and thanks for the cooking ideas!

  9. You are the person I look to for all things tomato ...

  10. MMMMM, tomatoes.... mine are only just starting to ripen because we live so far north and because (gulp) I planted late this year.

  11. Hi Farmgirl,

    I recommend when you go on your next fried pie expedition (I mean auction) you look for a toaster oven. I run a long extension cord from the house in the summer and do my tomato roasting outside. Tossing some roasted tomatoes, pasta, pesto and feta cheese together in the summer is FAB. But I'll definately be trying your 7 second solution too!


  12. This would be good in a gyro or falafel sammich :-)

  13. It't that time of year, too many tomatoes. Here in NM it is time to freeze green chiles so I just don't have room for too many other veggies. I have given them away to my neighbors, the local senior citizens and we have them every evening no matter what else. I put them on pizza, pasta, baked potato, pestos, but still...too many, yipes!

  14. Thanks, Farmgirl for brightening my day!

  15. last year I had some tomato sorbet, and it was the most delicious thing I could imagine having on a hot summer day. They served it with a sweet balsamic vinegar and bits of basil I think.

  16. I think some tomato canning is called for...Then you could save them for pasta sauce, or chili on those cold, frosty winter nights..and give some jars as gifts! I'll forward my home addy to ya! LOL!

  17. I hear ya, sista! I am so up to here with tomatoes,(making finger to neck slash) I started making juice out of them for fun. I like your recipe and I make some good yogurt cheese with cheese cloth and a lot of time so I will try this! I had pesto last night for dinner! I put it on some smoked fish (the left overs from a catering event that I am doing)

    Back to the kitchen!

  18. So yogurt cheese is basically yogurt that has been drained for another 24 hours or so??? Could I just use cheesecloth?

  19. Yogurt cheese??? How in the world did I ever forget about yogurt cheese? Goodness I need to get back in my own kitchen... and thanks for the idea I did come in to find a use for my glut of tomatoes.



December 2015 update: Hi! For some reason I can't figure out, Blogger hasn't been letting me leave comments on my own blog (!) for the last several months, so I've been unable to respond to your comments and questions. My apologies for any inconvenience! You're always welcome to email me: farmgirlfare AT gmail DOT com.

Hi! Thanks for visiting Farmgirl Fare and taking the time to write. While I'm not always able to reply to every comment, I receive and enjoy reading them all.

Your feedback is greatly appreciated, and I especially love hearing about your experiences with my recipes. Comments on older posts are always welcome!

Please note that I moderate comments, so if I'm away from the computer it may be a while before yours appears.

I try my best to answer all questions, though sometimes it takes me a few days. And sometimes, I'm sorry to say, they fall through the cracks, and for that I sincerely apologize.

I look forward to hearing from you and hope you enjoy your e-visits to our farm!